Again I had Gilbert and Sullivan's "Trial By Jury" running through my head all of yesterday, while I was downtown at the LA County Courthouse. Even better: I had my MP3 player with me, so could listen to it :-)
USHER And when, amid the plaintiff's shrieks,
The ruffianly defendant speaks--
Upon the other side;
What he may say you needn't mind---
From bias free of every kind,
This trial must be tried!
The best bit about jury selection is hearing the vast range of occupations and backgrounds as each of the jurors are interviewed by the judge and then the defence attorney and the prosecutor.
A couple of very successful ways of being excused were demonstrated. The first was a woman who at some point was asked:
Judge: And could you carry out your duty by presuming the defendant is innocent until proven guilty?
Woman: No
Judge: No?
Woman: No
Judge: Could you explain?
Woman: Where I come from, he's assumed guilty until proven innocent.
Judge: And where do you come from?
Woman: Vietnam. When I was growing up as a little girl there, this was the way.
Judge: Could you put that aside and use the American way, and assume innocence?
Woman: I'd find that very hard
So, she was dismissed. Nice one. Perhaps I should work on my French accent for next time.
Another woman was articulate and intelligent during her questions. She held a senior position as a software systems designer. The questions finally went like this:
Judge: Do you feel that you could do your duty as a juror in this case?
Woman: Yes
Judge: Would you be impartial?
Woman: No
Judge: No?
Woman: (confidently) No!
Judge: You could not be impartial?
Woman: I would not.
After some puzzled looks all around, the judge rephrased his question.
Judge: Would you be fair to the defendant and not assume his guilt or innocence either way?
Woman: Yes!
Judge: Ah, I see. I think we have a language problem here.
It was evident that the woman was confused about the difference between "partial" and "impartial". So, she was dismissed, too ... since I suppose having someone on the jury who gets confused between such key words is a bit of a liability for both sides!